Happy National Pizza Day!
Like most teenagers, I often find myself craving a good slice of pizza. Fortunately, Elkhart Lake has no shortage of delicious options! Recently, I visited five local spots to indulge in some mouthwatering pizza. Each pizza offered its own unique flavors and features, making it tough to choose a favorite. Check out all of the places you can grab a slice for yourself or the whole family.
Harry’s Pizza e Vino
111 E Rhine Street, Elkhart Lake
One of the few restaurants in the state licensed to make Roman-style crust, my decision at Harry’s was a tough one. After much deliberation, I opted for the Beef Marsala pizza, which featured a light, airy, and crunchy crust topped with big pieces of pot-roast style beef and a tasty glaze. Honestly, you can’t go wrong with any pizza at Harry’s.
Lake Street Café
21 South Lake Street, Elkhart Lake
My go-to at Lake Street Café is the Mushroom and Truffle Pizza. Wood-fired to perfections, it’s rich and creamy with parmesan cheese and has just the right amount of truffle oil. If it’s your first time trying truffles, you’re sure to love the unique flavor.
Anchor Lanes
230 Lincoln Street, Elkhart Lake
After bowling a few games and working up an appetite, pizza is a great option at Anchor Lanes. Made from scratch behind the bar, I ordered a sausage and onion pizza, and it sure hit the spot. It was cheesy goodness!
All Seasons Family Restaurant
510 E. Rhine Street, Elkhart Lake
I stopped by All Seasons for a quick lunch one Saturday afternoon and went for their ham, mushroom, and onion pizza. The crunchy crust with a light sauce would be great for parties or a quick takeout from the counter.
Otto’s Restaurant – The Osthoff Resort
101 Osthoff Avenue, Elkhart Lake
Located on the lower level of The Osthoff Resort, my choice at Otto’s was the Barbeque Chicken wood-fired pizza. The crust was super fluffy, and the tangy sauce was a great complement to the juicy chicken on the pie. Bonus: During the month of February, Otto’s pizzas come out in the shape of a heart.
As you can see you could eat pizza for days in Elkhart Lake. We are lucky to have so many delicious options to choose from in our small village. Go try a slice today!
Meet The Author
Canyon is a Junior at Elkhart Lake-Glenbeulah High School with a passion for racing. He currently drives for the Pure Energy Go Kart team at Road America, where he hones his skills on the track. Outside of racing, Canyon is an avid food enthusiast and loves dining out in Elkhart Lake with his family. Whether it’s trying local favorites or discovering new spots, Canyon enjoys exploring the vibrant food scene in his hometown.
